I’ve been reading more than writing this week, of note, hanging out at Nancy White’s Full Circle Online Blog. She has an interesting post on the fluidity of boundaries in online communities. Three things of particular interest:
1. “the only ‘home’ we have is the experience of place we create in our minds. We have too many online spaces.” I can’t (for now) wrap my head around Facebook. Others seem to be finding flaws, and articulating them better than I. Though unwilling to participate in Facebook itself, I seem to be spending a curious amount of time lurking around other peoples conversations about Facebook — at the office, in the “parent” section of my kids’ activities, even in restaurants, where I would rather NOT hear the man at the table next to me loudly proclaim he doesn’t want to talk to “those people” from highschool because there’s “a reason“ he hasn’t talked to them in 20 years. And yet, this last bit of inadvertent eavesdropping is quite telling… online or on life, people are more and less discriminating (present company included) about different things. I don’t necessarily think ill of Facebook as a concept, I just haven’t found a meaningful application, for me, for now;
2. the genesis of today’s title, there seem to be continually “greater risks that we will find it easier to walk away from dissent and divergence, rather than figuring out what to do, because it is easy to pick up one’s toys and migrate to another sandbox.” Certainly, the lack of material investment in a particular online community might make it seem easier to just “pack up and go.” But maybe the challenge is more along the lines of ”buyer beware” — are we thinking critically about where and when we maintain a presence online? Does it really matter? If so, to whom? As my preservice teacher candidates are beginning to realize, photos of extracurricular drinking activities may garner social capital (in some “communities”), but can be a barrier to economic capital when potential employers do web searches before hiring people to ”touch the future“; and finally,
3. “the creative and destructive tension between control and emergence feels bigger than ever before.” Exactly. Even these quotes are out of order from the way they were originally written. Online and on life, the re:production is producing even as we attempt to produce it.
As ever, many questions, few if any answers,
L.